This report is an independent peer review of the proposed mining methods in the PAG5 study for Spring Creek Mines Panel 9 - 13. The study has found that the mining method and extraction methodologies are sound for the range of conditions confronting the mining team but there are a number of important matters that need to be fully addressed: old workings, mining method, management plans, mine planning, reserves, production assumptions, mine services and infrastructure, and considerations for financial modelling.